State investigates Hispanic Cultural Center Foundation
State Department of Cultural Affairs (DCA) Secretary Veronica N. Gonzales has ordered a “full and independent” audit of how the National Hispanic Cultural Center Foundation spent $812,500 in state funds lawmakers provided for completion of the Center’s Torreon Building fresco in Albuquerque, DCA spokesman Doug Svetnicka confirmed Thursday.
Citing “serious mistakes with the distribution of funds for this project,” Gonzales demanded Foundation President Clara Apodaca return a total of $379,855 to the state, in a letter dated March 30.
The Foundation already returned the $138,361 unspent balance of that money in a response from Apodaca dated March 31, Svetnicka confirmed.
“We do not know at this time the specific amount of additional monies that will be repaid,” Svetnicka wrote in an e-mail to Veritas New Mexico. “Sec. Gonzales has initiated an independent audit of this project that will help determine this amount.”
The Legislature made three appropriations in 2007 and 2008 totaling $812,500 for the completion of Santa Fe muralist Frederico Vigil’s Torreon Building fresco, depicting New Mexico’s Spanish and Native American history.
That money was to go toward production of the fresco, but the money was sent directly to the Center’s independent fundraising Foundation instead of to the Center. The Foundation subsequently spent nearly 30 percent of that money — $241,494 – on “impermissible” expenses, according to Gonzales’s letter — including documentary films about the fresco and “administrative fees” that went to reimbursing Foundation lobbying, meal and salary expenses.
Gonzales is traveling this week and was unavailable for comment, Svetnicka said.
Apodaca would not speak with Veritas Wednesday, or even schedule an interview about Foundation finances.
But in a copy of Gonzales’s March 30 letter to Apodaca, provided by Svetnicka Thursday morning, Gonzales requested the return of $138,360.97 of unexpended state fresco money, plus another $241,494 of fresco money already spent by the Foundation for items deemed “impermissible” under state laws and regulations.
In her March 31 response letter to Gonzales, Apodaca questions the DCA’s authority to perform an external audit on the Foundation, which is a private, nonprofit corporation, but “welcomes DCA to perform an independent external audit of all financials should they deem it necessary.”
Apodaca also notes in the letter that under previous DCA secretary Stuart Ashman, an internal DCA “audit” was performed on fresco project expenditures, and that it concluded the Foundation had “adequately accounted for all funds.”
In reality, that inquiry was a “Special Review” conducted by DCA auditor Michael Miera — not a formal audit.
Miera’s special review report, dated Dec. 21, 2010, noted several problems, including:
- The absence of a signed memo of understanding (MOU) between the state and the Foundation, laying out how the legislative appropriations sent to the Foundation should be spent. (Without this document, the dispersal of state funds to the Foundation may have violated the state Constitution’s Anti-Donation Clause.)
- The Foundation’s use of state money for the fresco, to “reimburse” the Foundation for previous payments to the artist (which were made with private donors’ money).
- The hiring of a Foundation staffer as a documentary film producer with $38,045 of the state fresco appropriation funds.
- Missing invoices and records for $10,000 spent on an item listed as “First Video – Fresco.”
Former Center board member Matt Martinez, who publicly alleged Nov. 18 the Foundation had misappropriated state fresco funds, had called for independent audits by the IRS and State Auditor Hector Balderas.
But Apodaca assured Balderas in a Dec. 28 e-mail that a signed copy of the missing MOU had been located, that no further reimbursements to the Foundation for previous expenses would occur, and that the Foundation had adopted a “Conflict of Interest procedure” to avoid hiring Foundation staffers as contractors in the future. (The Foundation’s 2008 IRS tax returns stated that a conflict of interest policy was already in place. Veritas has asked the Foundation for copies of both policy documents.)
However, the MOU, a copy of which was obtained from the DCA, while signed by Ashman and Apodaca, was not dated. That raises questions about its legal standing and whether it was signed before or after the Foundation was given state funds.
Photo courtesy of Peter St. Cyr.
Documents cited in this report
March 31, 2011 response from Foundation CEO Apodaca
Foundation CEO Apodaca’s Dec. 28, 2010 e-mail to State Auditor Hector Balderas
Foundation’s 2008 IRS tax returns
Undated Foundation memo of understanding with Dept. of Cultural Affairs
I love the fact that the lame MOU “document” Ms. Apodaca grants the
State of NM some free tickets to the opening of its own property! Where do these elitists get off anyway? The Torreon, as does the entire NHCC, belongs to the people of the State of NM!!! And, why should Stewey Ashman get his name on a plaque–for collusion?
The two investigative pieces published today by Veritas and written by Bryant Furlow are decisive journalistic examinations that address negligent mismanagement, grave violations of state and possible federal laws, and a continued demonstration of corruption and misconduct in state government.
The information reveled in today’s articles make public the sham and shame of continued wrongdoing and unethical behavior by those we are to place our public trust in. Ironically former board member Matt Martinez’s “15 minutes of fame,” as referenced by Ms. Apodoca in her e-mail to former secretary Stuart Ashman, are turning into her legacy of disgrace and misdeeds.
It astounds me – though it shouldn’t – that people like Clara Apodaca continue to flourish in positions of authority. The letter released by the Governor’s Secretary of Cultural Affairs is however disingenuous. Are we to believe that this is all new news to the incoming administration when Mr. Edward Lujan is reportedly very close to the new secretary, the governor and Clara Apodaca?
Someone should look at minutes of past NHCC board meetings. The record will probably reveal that Mr. Lujan has known all along about this misconduct and mismanagement and neglected to do anything about it. To the contrary he has been Clara Apodaca’s most ardent defender and protector. This is the same man who donated tens of thousands of dollars to Governor Martinez’ campaign and was named into a key position for her transition committee for the department of cultural affairs.
The truly sad and regrettable thing about all this is that a dark cloud has been cast over an institution, which has so much promise and potential to succeed. Even more regrettable is the loss of the now former executive director Dr. Estevan Rael Galvez, who is known to have brought these matters to the attention of both boards and secretaries of cultural affairs for quite sometime. Yet, he was driven out of his position by the political strong-arming of Apodaca and Lujan. Dr. Rael Galvez is an exceptional administrator and prodigious scholar whose work and leadership at the NHCC will leave an everlasting and positive impact for years to come. New Mexico is very fortunate to have had such a critical thinking, public intellectual at the helm of the National Hispanic Cultural Center.
In addition to Ed Lujan, where were all the other foundation board members? Ultimately these are the people charged with maintaining the public’s trust and the integrity of the institution along with oversight of Apodaca’s activities. And from an IRS legal standpoint the foundation board is ultimately financially accountable and liable for Apodaca’s financial mismanagement.
I hope that other high ranking politicians like the state’s attorney general and state auditor who should have already taken action, now step up and act on behalf of the greater good of our state as their oath of office stipulates…but don’t hold your breadth because these guys are already on to their next political campaign.
It is time to have Clara Apodaca removed from the NHCC foundation and to have the foundation dissolved. The foundations continued presence is only detrimental and debilitating to this very important institution.
Leave your response!
Our Mission
Our mission is to become the most trusted online watchdog news site in New Mexico, offering compelling, nonpartisan reporting in the public interest.
From simple fact-check or data mapping stories to in-depth investigations, our reporting on government, regulation, public health, the economy and education will examine how government policies affect New Mexicans, while exposing abuses of power and betrayals of public trust.
Send tips/comments to:
news@veritasnm.com
All Categories
Data Links
Recent Comments
Veritas NM Social Links: